Best Ice Cream Shops on Marco Island

🍦 Best Ice Cream Shops on Marco Island

If you’re looking for a post-beach sugar fix, these are the most popular spots on the island:

🏆 Local Favorite

Sweet Annie’s Ice Cream Parlour

• One of Marco Island’s original ice cream shops, serving locals and visitors since 1986.

• More than 40 flavors plus vintage candy, retro sodas, and old-school ice cream parlor charm.

• Family-friendly and consistently one of the highest-rated dessert spots on the island. (Tripadvisor)

🍨 Classic Marco Walk Stop

Beebe’s Ice Cream

• Located in Marco Walk Plaza across from the beach resorts.

• Known for a huge flavor selection, waffle cones, milkshakes, frozen yogurt, and generous portions.

• Great evening stop after dinner at Marco Walk. (AllBiz)

🇮🇹 Best Gelato

Dolce Mare

• Handmade gelato, Italian ice, espresso drinks, chocolates, cannoli, and other Italian desserts.

• Excellent choice if you’re in the mood for authentic gelato rather than traditional ice cream.

🍋 Hidden Gem

Mr Bentley’s Ice Cream Shop

• Smaller shop with homemade flavors and a cozy neighborhood feel.

• Visitors frequently mention creative flavors and friendly service.

🥄 Mix-In Creations

Cold Stone Creamery

• National chain where ice cream is mixed with toppings on a frozen granite stone.

• Good option if you like customized combinations and signature creations.

📍 My Top 3 Picks

1. 🍦 Sweet Annie’s Ice Cream Parlour – Best overall experience

2. 🍨 Beebe’s Ice Cream – Best traditional beach-vacation ice cream stop

3. 🇮🇹 Dolce Mare – Best gelato and Italian desserts

For a classic Marco Island evening, many visitors grab dinner, watch the sunset, then head to Sweet Annie’s or Beebe’sfor dessert. 🍦🌴 (Tripadvisor)