🍴 Marco Island Foodie Guide: The Carvelli Restaurant Group — Family, Flavor & Island Flair

If you’ve ever wondered what happens when Italian passion meets paradise, the answer is simple: the Carvelli Restaurant Group. Rooted in family, tradition, and unforgettable food, the Carvelli and Serravalle families have transformed Marco Island’s dining scene into a culinary love letter—one plate at a time.

Their story began in Mesoraca, Italy, where meals were more than just food—they were memories shared around the table. Today, that same warmth, care, and hospitality flow through their Marco Island restaurants, where locals and visitors alike come together to eat, laugh, and live well.

Here’s your insider’s guide to each delicious stop on the Carvelli family’s map of flavor 👇

🥩 Marco Prime Steaks & Seafood

📍 599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL
💎 Vibe: Upscale, Modern, Effortlessly Elegant

Step into Marco Prime and prepare to be spoiled. This sleek steakhouse delivers serious flavor with a side of sophistication. Prime cuts, perfectly grilled seafood, craft cocktails—it’s where indulgence meets intention.

The staff here aren’t just servers; they’re storytellers, guiding you through an evening of flavor and finesse. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone or just treating yourself, Marco Prime makes every night feel like a special occasion.

⭐ Foodie Favorite: The bone-in ribeye paired with truffle mac and cheese. Add a full-bodied red and thank us later.

🌴 The Snook Inn

📍 1215 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL
🎶 Vibe: Laid-back, Local Legend, Waterfront Icon

A true Marco Island institution, The Snook Inn has been serving sunshine and seafood for over 30 years. Think toes-in-the-sand vibes meets live music and the kind of sunsets you can’t capture with a filter.

From conch fritters to fresh Gulf shrimp, the menu celebrates everything that makes island dining unforgettable. Grab a cocktail, snag a seat by the water, and let the local musicians set your rhythm for the night.

☀️ Foodie Favorite: The grouper sandwich with a cold draft beer—simple, fresh, perfect.

🦪 The Oyster Society

📍 599 S Collier Blvd Suite 103, Marco Island, FL
🍷 Vibe: Chic, Coastal, Italian Sophistication

For those who crave a little glam with their oysters, The Oyster Society is your sanctuary. Inspired by the elegance of vintage Italy and the bounty of the Gulf, this restaurant delivers an experience that’s both refined and inviting.

The menu? A culinary passport—from artisan pasta to expertly shucked oysters. The wine list and handcrafted cocktails seal the deal for an indulgent evening worth dressing up for.

💫 Foodie Favorite: Start with a dozen oysters and finish with the seafood risotto—pure perfection.

🍝 DaVincie’s

📍 970 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL
🇮🇹 Vibe: Classic Italian, Cozy, Family-Friendly

DaVincie’s brings the heart of Italy straight to Marco Island with traditional pasta, brick-oven pizza, and fresh seafood. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for a casual family dinner or a romantic night out. Each dish is prepared with the same care and authenticity that the Carvelli and Serravalle families are known for, making it a must-visit for anyone craving true Italian flavor.

🍕 Foodie Favorite: Wood-fired Margherita pizza and homemade lasagna, paired with a glass of Chianti.

🍦 Sweet Annie’s

📍 692 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL
🍭 Vibe: Nostalgic, Whimsical, Family Fun

When it’s time to satisfy your sweet tooth, Sweet Annie’s is the cherry (or sprinkles) on top of the Carvelli experience. A beloved Marco Island staple, it’s equal parts ice cream parlor and candy wonderland.

Grab a scoop of hand-dipped ice cream, fill a bag from the colorful candy wall, and browse through their vintage soda collection. Whether you’re eight or eighty, you’ll leave with a smile—and probably a sugar rush.

🍨 Foodie Favorite: Homemade brownie sundae with a scoop of chocolate peanut butter. Trust us.

❤️ Why Foodies Love the Carvelli Experience

The Carvelli Restaurant Group isn’t just about food—it’s about connection. Each restaurant is a reflection of what dining should be: personal, flavorful, and memorable. From high-end dinners to casual bites by the water, their family philosophy remains the same:

“Serve others the way we’d want to be served.”

That spirit has turned meals into memories and visitors into regulars. Whether you’re sipping wine under the stars at The Oyster Society or watching the sunset at The Snook Inn, you’re part of the Carvelli family the moment you sit down.

🌺 Foodie Insider Tip:

Plan a full Carvelli Food Crawl—start with lunch at Snook Inn, sunset dinner at Marco Prime, finish with pizza at DaVincie’s, dessert at Sweet Annie’s, and a nightcap at The Oyster Society. That’s a Marco Island evening done right.

📸 Follow the Flavor:
👉 @marcoprimerestaurant
👉 @thesnookinn
👉 @theoystersociety
👉 @sweetanniesmarcoisland
👉 @ristorantedavinci